Sixteen year-old Rebekah and her boyfriend Braeden are perfect for each other: they're hard-working, intelligent, and kind, and they both love animals more than anything in the world. But there's one fatal difference: Rebekah is Amish and Braeden is "English."
Braeden surprises Rebekah with exciting news: he's been accepted to a competitive pre-veterinary summer internship, and his supervisor has invited Rebekah along. It's the perfect opportunity for Rebekah, who's always wanted to be a vet.
As Rebekah spends more time with Braeden, she feels like she's leading a double life. She knows that she can't continue to live the worldly "English" life and remain true to her Amish faith. She also feels torn between her love for her family and community and her desire to pursue her education and continue her relationship with Braeden.
Now, Rebekah is faced with a heart-breaking question: What life is right for her, "English" or Amish? What life will she choose?