When local vixen, Desdemona, discovers that Clarence, the object of her affection, is snubbing her as he pines for the lovely "Bunnie" Daniels, she enlists the aid of Paul Rily to seduce her out of the way. Genuine sparks fly as Bunnie and Paul spend increasing amounts of time together, but after he’s assaulted by her family when the "seduction job" comes to light, Bunnie takes on insurmountable odds to make it up to him, culminating in a sequin-filled, underwater extravaganza. "A Simple Love Story, Psyche!" is the classic myth of Psyche and Cupid, put in a modern setting, and given a fun twist.