Landscapes of Law: Practicing Sovereignty in Transnational Terrain

International scholars offer ethnographic analyses of the relations between transnationalism, law, and culture

The recent surge of right-wing populism in Europe and the United States is widely perceived as evidence of ongoing challenges to the policies and institutions of globalization. But as editors Carol J. Greenhouse and Christina L. Davis observe in their introduction to Landscapes of Law, the appeal to national culture is not restricted to the ethno-nationalisms of the developing world outside of industrial democracies nor to insurgent groups within them. The essays they have collected in this volume reveal how claims of national culture emerge in the pursuit of transnationalism and, under some circumstances, become embedded within international law. The premise that there is inherent tension between nationalism and globalism is misleading. Whether asserted explicitly as state sovereignty or implicitly as cultural community, claims of national culture mediate how governments assert their interests and values when engaging with transnational law. Landscapes of Law demonstrates how nationalism operates in the contested zone between borderless capital and bordered states.

Drawing from the fields of anthropology, international relations, law, political science, and sociology, the book’s international contributors examine the ways in which claims of national differences are produced within transnational institutions. Insights from case studies across a wide range of topics reveal how such claims may be worked into policy prescriptions and legal arrangements or provide ad hoc bargaining chips. Together, they show that expressions of national culture outside of state boundaries consolidate claims of sovereignty. The contributors offer innovative frameworks for analyzing the relationships among transnationalism, law, and cultural claims at various levels and scales. They demonstrate how overlapping communities use law to define borders and shape relationships among actors rather than to generate a single social ordering.

Landscapes of Law traces the theoretical implications generated by an understanding of transnational law that challenges the conventional separation of individual, community, society, national, and international spaces.

Contributors: Katayoun Alidadi, Tugba Basaran, Rachel Brewster, Sandra Brunnegger, Christina L. Davis, Sara Dezalay, Marie-Claire Foblets, Henry Gao, Carol J. Greenhouse, David Leheny, Mark Fathi Massoud, Teresa Rodríguez-de-las-Heras Ballell, Gregory Shaffer, Mariana Valverde.

Carol J. Greenhouse is the Arthur W. Marks ’19 Professor of Anthropology Emeritus at Princeton University. She is author and editor of numerous books, including Ethnographies of Neoliberalism and The Paradox of Relevance: Ethnography and Citizenship in the United States, both available from the University of Pennsylvania Press.

Christina L. Davis is Professor in the Department of Government at Harvard University and the Susan S. and Kenneth L. Wallach Professor at the Radcliffe Institute. She is author of Why Adjudicate? Enforcing Trade Rules in the WTO and Food Fights Over Free Trade: How International Institutions Promote Agricultural Trade Liberalization.