The Tall Poppy Syndrome: The Joy of Cutting Others Down

As heard in a 2018 episode of The Hidden Brain, the tall poppy syndrome is a human condition that has been present in every society from the beginning of time. It explains why we seek out equality and justify our actions by cutting others down. With over 600 citations, The Tall Poppy Syndrome: The Joy of Cutting Others Down is the most comprehensive book on the subject.

Doug Garland has been studying the phenomenon for over 10 years after he experienced it first hand in his own career. His work brings awareness and clarity to a hidden and often misunderstood human condition. Using both recent examples and case studies through history we can begin to better understand the emotional damage and challenges Tall Poppies face.

Douglas Garland, M.D. practiced orthopedic surgery for 37 years in Southern California. Dr. Garland was the Clinical Professor of Orthopedics at the University of Southern California where he authored over 100 peer-reviewed scientific articles.

A Tall Poppy, in Australian terms, is someone noticeably successful as defined by wealth, prestige, prowess, rank or even birth that may attract hostility, envious attention, or malevolence. Some people holding this Tall Poppy person in contempt may attempt to cause failure or disgrace by ＂cutting＂ him or her ＂down to size＂; thus causing their target to be ＂tall-poppied＂ as a victim of the ＂Tall Poppy Syndrome＂ (TPS). Awareness of TPS is rarely noted in the United States despite being documented in most countries using various metaphors, words, or phrases. For the English-speaking world, reviewing research from Australia and New Zealand, where the Tall Poppy Syndrome is a national pastime, is crucial to understanding the metaphor. Once we grasp the metaphor, a brief study of where it originated exemplifies the drama that has played out time and again through history. Notice the use of negative words such as conspicuously, envious, hostility, contempt, downfall, ruin, and denigrating. We might assume TPS, TPs, and cutters are never good. As clarified in the introduction, however, good and bad forms of each exist, and TPs are not necessarily well known. A look at the understanding of TPS through the years reveals that the definitions have not kept up with evolving connotations. Nationally, America is politically divided between two main groups but within this division are other potentially divisive tribes.

＂Those who can, do; those who can’t, tall poppy.＂

There has always been income inequality in capitalism but the unequal are now being heard. This national scene has only added to the more personal envy-competition scene of everyday life which includes friends, colleagues, and professionals in the same fields which has dramatically increased simply because of population growth. People are not moving up leaving a greater swath of mass which are equal. In spite of the metaphor, it is really the nearly equal who cut each other down especially as we lose our potential upward mobility... The rise of the group versus the individual, the population growth and the political scene increase the likelihood of opportunities for Tall Poppy Syndrome which has been uncommon in America. This book will aid readers in understanding the dynamics as well as some opportunities to thwart it.