In 2008, a monograph entitled "The Origins of the Samanids" was published in Tashkent. The author is a doctor of historical sciences, Professor Sh. This review shows the inconsistency of scientific methods and methodology of the Uzbek scientist in studying the origin of Samanids. The material is intended for historians, orientalists, teachers, university students, teachers, and all those interested in the history of the peoples of Central Asia and Iran.